this I believe . . . about basic dignity

I try not to use this blog space to rant or be preachy. I’m not a fan of ranting or sermons (unless it’s Sunday - and even then it really depends on the sermon).
Think of this as a desperate plea.
Yesterday, while I was trying to enjoy my manicure, I watched in horror as the two women across from me talked on their phones the entire time they were getting their manicures. They employed head nods, eyebrow raises, and finger pointing to instruct the manicurists on things like nail length and polish choices.
I really couldn't believe it.
I’ve had my nails done by the same two women for 10 years. I know their names (their real Vietnamese names), their children’s names, and many of their stories. They know my name, my children’s names, and many of my stories. When I finally made a comment about the women on their cell phones, they both quickly averted their eyes. Finally, in a whisper, Susan said, “They don’t know. Most of them don’t think of us as real people.”
On the way home, I stopped at Barnes & Noble to pick up a magazine. The woman ahead of me in line bought two books, applied for a new “reader card,” and asked to get one book gift wrapped without getting off of her cell phone. She plowed through the entire exchange without making eye contact or directly speaking to the young woman working at the counter. She never acknowledged the presence of the human being across from her.
After leaving Barnes & Noble, I drove through the Chick-fil-A drive-thru to get a Diet Dr. Pepper. Right as I pulled up to the window, my cell phone rang. I wasn’t quite sure, but I thought it might be Charlie’s school calling. I answered it. It wasn’t Charlie’s school – it was someone calling to confirm my hair appointment. I got off the phone as quickly as I could.
In the short time it took me to say, “Yes, I’ll be at my appointment,” the woman in the window and I had finished our soda-for-money transaction. I apologized to her the second I got off of the phone. I said, “I’m so sorry. The phone rang right when I was pulling up and I thought it was my son’s school.”
I must have surprised her because she got huge tears in her eyes and said, “Thank you. Thank you so much. You have no idea how humiliating it is sometimes. They don’t even see us.”
I don’t know how it feels for her, but I do know how it feels to be an invisible member of the service industry. It can suck.
I worked my way through undergrad and some of graduate school by waiting tables. I worked in a really nice restaurant that was close to campus and a hot spot for wealthy college kids and their parents (parents who were visiting for the weekend and treating their kids and their kids’ friends to dinner). I was in my late 20’s and praying to finish my bachelor’s degree before I hit 30.
When the customers were kind and respectful, it was OK, but one “waiter as object” moment could tear me apart. Unfortunately, I now see those moments happening all of the time.
I see adults who don’t even look at their waiters when they speak to them. I see parents who let their young children talk down to store clerks. I see people rage and scream at receptionists then treat the bosses/doctors/bankers with the utmost respect.
And, I see the insidious nature of race, class, and privilege playing out in one of the most historically damaging ways possible – the server/served relationship.
Everyone wants to know why customer service has gone to hell in a handbasket.
I want to know why customer behavior has gone to hell in a handbasket.
When we treat people as objects, we dehumanize them. We do something really terrible to their souls and to our own.
Martin Buber, an Austrian-born philosopher, wrote about the differences between an "I-it" relationship and an "I-you" relationship. An "I-it" relationship is basically what we create when we are in transactions with people whom we treat like objects - people who are simply there to serve us or complete a task.
I-you relationships are characterized by human connection and empathy.
I’m not suggesting that we engage in a deep, meaningful relationship with the man who works at the cleaners or the woman who works at the drive-thru, but I am suggesting that we stop dehumanizing people and start looking them in the eye when we speak to them. If we don’t have the energy or time to do that, we should stay at home.
And, for the love of humankind, we need to get off of our damn phones and show some basic respect to the people who are standing in front of us.
Buber wrote, “When two people relate to each other authentically and humanly, God is the electricity that surges between them.”
I just don’t think treating each other with basic dignity is asking too much.
Thoughts? Ideas? Comments?
This article also ran in the Houston Chronicle and on MOREmagazine.com.















06.16.2009
Reader Comments (197)
And you can rant and be preachy anytime, if that's the way you're feeling. I'm just looking for authenticity here :) (And you never disappoint.)
I know I would be a much better parent if I had help cleaning my house (I would resent less, nag less, and have more time), but I am terrified of that role, of erring on either side of being too aloof and demanding, or being a doormat and cleaning the house from top to bottom before someone else came to do it. It should be simple to hire someone with respect and dignity but instead it seems overwhelming...
I'd love to hear more of your thoughts on this.
It amazed me how people can make you feel like a vending machine. I think each one of those people should have to work front counter at least an hour and see how it changes them.
Thanks for the support!
~wynn
One of the things that I'm trying to underscore to my boys, raised as they are in the time they are, is that all the technology can be great, but we did not die when I was growing up and everyone was not immediately reachable. Emergencies did not go unanswered, and perhaps the calls we missed meant more human-human, face to face interaction. More being in the moment we are living. I think it is worth asking, what are we losing out on by being so plugged in?
Great, great post.
on the note of cell phone use, i think our technologies should be used to help us, not to take over our lives. it is the strangest feeling to be in a conversation with someone and their eyes are flickering downwards to check their texts (and type them!) while 'listening'. huh?
okay, i'll stop, haha
At his elementary school this year, a mom drove off with THE WRONG KID in the backseat. The teacher had made a mistake and put the wrong child in the car and the mom was on her cell and didn't notice!
It's simple human courtesy.
I think a little bit of respect goes a long way, and so often I notice that the more friendly I am to people (people providing me a service or just people in general), the more of a lift I get from their response - it's a genuine interaction.
Everyone seems so busy trying to be in touch with the people who are not really around them right at that moment. And they miss what is right in front of them. And it is such a great loss.
The cell phones have got to go...I don't even want to be in the grocery sometimes because I have to hear people talking about their personal biz so loudly-it is just plain rude. Most of the time they are talking about someone to someone else. YUCK. It sort of makes me feel like a need a shower after the things I have overheard.
AMEN, sister!
My husband and I have both been able to hold off on getting a cell phone. One reason we keep holding back is because we see (and feel) the impact of others on their cell phones at the expense of the people they are with. I *know* how easily I could become one of 'those' people. It's a real inconvenience sometimes and we have to use good old fashioned pay phones every now and then. We know we could get one if we wanted to. We're both professionals and have good salaries. We're just rebelling and choosing to keep our lives simpler.
I've love that you've brought this into the light. It a reminder for me to be present and engaged with everyone I meet.
This weekend our family was visiting my aunt, who is also my godmother, and someone I love and respect very much. My daughter stood in her kitchen, looking through photos she had taken at the family reunion earlier that day, and deleting the ones she didn't like. When my aunt spoke to her to offer her a soda, she didn't even look up! She answered, but didn't even really acknowledge my aunt as a person. I was so embarrassed, and the next morning I made sure to tell her so. It didn't even register; she insisted she had not acted that way! Sometimes I wonder what this world is coming to. There, I said it, even though I realize it sounds like something my mother would have said back in the day! My husband and I work hard to raise our kids right, and seeing our kids act this way is incredibly demoralizing.
It feels as though they are reducing the significance of my profession, for which I have a bachelors degree and am now working towards a doctorate, while I am genuinely concerned with their health and health outcomes. I have worked with pharmacists before who refuse to serve customers on cell phones, whether at the register, the drop-off window or at the consultation booth. Society truly needs a cellphone-ectomy, not only for the sake of re-humanizing those of us in the service industry, but also for their own health and safety.
P.S. I'm following you on Twitter now bcs of this post.
that's it.
just love you.
standin' up and clappin'!
ter
Along those same lines -- went to Central Market yesterday, love the place, but some of the shoppers...does NOBODY say excuse me anymore BEFORE they mow past you with their cart??? (mistakenly thought Monday would be a more friendly day to go, not so much)
I'm sad for these people who are so attached to their phones, who think that their conversation that they are having is so VERY important that they can't stop and be polite- much less friendly- to people who are helping them in some way. They have no idea what they're missing out on.
More for the rest of us, I suppose :)
Your story about waiting tables reminded me of a date I had years ago. We met for dinner at a popular restaurant known for excellent food and service. He treated the poor waitress like dirt under his feet, and knew exactly what he was doing.
"I love treating these people this way, because I can. They can't do anything about it."
He seemed shocked when he asked for a second date and I refused.
"Why?"
"Because I'm not interested in someone who treats people badly just because he can."
Am I really the only one who has BEEN "that person" at least once?
How about some shared experiences?
HOW DID YOU FEEL WHEN YOU REALIZED YOU WEREN'T "SEEING" OTHER PEOPLE AND HONORING THEIR DIGNITY?
LIke I wasn't honoring my own. LIke I was a machine who wasn't allowing myself to see joy and beauty in the PRESENT. Disgusting. Alone, actually. Even when I was on the phone with a friend while checking out at Target, it felt LONELY to have such a barrier between me and the person with whom I was sharing the present moment.
WHAT MADE YOU CHANGE?
When I yelled at a pharmacist for not having my perscriptions ready on time when I was preparing for a trip. My flight left in two hours. I had already been to the pharmacy three times to get this filled. Still, no excuse. That woman is a human being. Who did I think I WAS? Here I was, going halfway around the world to study and volunteer, and I couldn't even treat the woman in my neighborhood Walgreens with the respect she deserved. A change was vital.
HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE OFF THE PHONE AND CONNECTING WITH OTHERS?
Alive. I see beauty everywhere. They are opportunities to learn about different people and to be inspired! When I SEE others, I SEE myself. When I stop treating others like robot, I stop treating myself like a robot.
ANYONE?
Sorry - I wrote a book here! I'm enjoying your blog and am thankful to Jen for recommending it! :)
Someone once pointed out that the real measure of our character isn't how we treat those who have power over us but rather how we treat those who serve us. My husband and I went out with two other couples one night. One of the women treated our server at a nice restaurant so rudely I found I distanced myself from her at work the following week.
It is rude to talk on the phone with unseen individuals while ignoring or getsuring to people right in front of us. No phone conversation is so important as to justify rudeness. When I worked retail over 20 years ago, we were taught to focus on the customer in front of us, not the one on the phone. The universe won't come to an end if we hang up the phone or *GASP* don't answer it at all.
Kate
"After reading all these comments I just have to ask.............
Am I really the only one who has BEEN "that person" at least once?
How about some shared experiences?"
YES! I've been that person. And, 9 times out of 10 it's been when I've been in a shitty, disconnected mood. Stress, fear, anxiety, shame - they've triggered those times for me. Because just like the people across from us, I'm human.
I would imagine that we've all been "that person." I'm sure I'll be her again.
When I have enough awareness to be off the phone and connecting or kind to someone who happens to be in the wrong place at the wrong time - it feels exactly how you described.
I think we're allowed to have those moments. I think people in the service industry are allowed to have those moments. I'm just afraid that what I'm seeing is not a collection of bad moments but the slow eroding of basic respect and kindness. I don't even think it's intentional. I think it's the result of living far beyond human scale.
Thank you so much for the brave "Hey you out there - it's us we're talking about!" comment.
I currently work two jobs- one as a full time office admin, and then part-time at a grocery store. You are so right... most days I feel invisible. I see women dressed in business suits with blue tooth devices in their ears and blackberries in their hands, and I see the scorn in their eyes as they peer down their noses at me- the "lowly grocery clerk". It makes my cheeks burn and I want to shout "You don't understand! I wear high heels and dress pants and have a real job too!" Then I get mad at myself for being ashamed of myself and my job.
Thoughts like yours make me lift my head back up and be proud of everything I do. :)